Not one we lead with. We can board this if you want it. It is not one we know inside out, so we would be setting it up rather than advising you on it — and we would tell you that before you signed anything. Talk it through with us.
Payroll & HR · ADP · via PayCompass
ADP
Payroll, HR, benefits and workers' comp for a business too small to have an HR person.
- Restaurant
- Retail
- Home services
- Professional services
- Medical & dental
- Any business
An independent assessment. Vigilant can place ADP, and is paid the same either way — which is why the drawbacks are on this page too.
What it is
Payroll is the complementary service most merchants ask about second, right after processing — usually because they are doing it themselves in a spreadsheet and quietly terrified of the filings.
ADP handles federal, state and local payroll filing automatically, connects to your general ledger, POS and HR software, and gives you a dashboard with your next payroll date, priority to-dos and alerts. Payroll Inspector flags likely errors before they are submitted, which is the feature that actually prevents penalty notices.
On the employee side: direct deposit, the Wisely pay card or paper cheques, an employee app, and perks including employee assistance and consumer discount programmes. On the employer side: 24/7 support from certified payroll experts, retirement plans, and pay-as-you-go workers' compensation so premiums track actual payroll instead of an annual estimate and a true-up bill.
Who it fits
Best for
Businesses running payroll by hand or through a bookkeeper, especially restaurants and trades with tipped wages, multiple pay rates and turnover.
Probably not ideal for
Very small operations with one or two salaried people and no complexity — the base fee will outweigh the benefit.
Key capabilities
- Automated filing
- Federal, state and local payroll tax filing handled automatically.
- Payroll Inspector
- Flags likely errors before submission, which is where penalties come from.
- Integrations
- Connects to your general ledger, POS and HR systems rather than sitting apart from them.
- Employee payment options
- Direct deposit, the Wisely pay card or paper cheques, plus an employee mobile app.
- Benefits and retirement
- Retirement plans with mobile engagement, plus employee assistance and discount programmes.
- Pay-as-you-go workers' comp
- Premiums track actual payroll instead of an estimate and an annual true-up.
- Support
- 24/7 access to certified payroll experts.
Strengths and tradeoffs
Strengths
- Filings and compliance handled at a scale no small provider matches — federal, state and local, correctly.
- Tip handling, overtime and multi-state payroll that hospitality and construction actually need.
- HR, benefits, onboarding and time tracking available as you grow into them.
- Liability for filing errors sits with a company large enough to carry it.
- Integrates with most major POS and time systems, so hours flow through without re-keying.
Tradeoffs
- Priced for the service level; a very small payroll can find it expensive per head.
- Modules and fees stack, and the quoted price often excludes things you will end up needing.
- Support runs through tiers, and continuity of contact is inconsistent.
- Contract terms and renewal deserve reading, as with any large provider.
- A five-person business with simple payroll may be better served by something lighter.
Pricing
Quoted by headcount and module. Compare it against the PayCompass payroll programme below — for a small headcount the difference is usually meaningful.
Pricing reflects what the vendor publishes or what we have seen quoted. Your actual terms depend on volume, card mix and what is negotiated — which is the part we do.
Vigilant's assessment
Payroll is the one area where getting it wrong is genuinely expensive, and ADP is the safe answer for anyone with tips, multiple states or more than a handful of staff. Get the module list scoped properly before signing, because that is where the price moves.
How it compares
Payroll is mostly a question of complexity and who carries the risk if a filing is wrong.
| Criterion | ADP Full-service payroll & HR | PayCompass Payroll Bundled with processing |
|---|---|---|
| Best at | Complex payroll and compliance at scale | Simple payroll alongside your processing |
| Multi-state | Yes | Limited |
| Tip handling | Strong | Basic |
| HR & benefits | Extensive | Minimal |
| Who carries filing risk | ADP | Shared |
| Cost per head | Higher | Lower |
| Vendors to manage | Separate from payments | One relationship |
| Pick it when | Tips, multiple states or real headcount | Payroll is simple and you value one bill |
Verdict. Tips, several states, or more than about fifteen staff: ADP. Simple payroll and a preference for one relationship: PayCompass Payroll.
Ready
Start now
Talk it through with someone who has installed ADP — including whether it is genuinely the right fit for you.
Start now
